Glory Years: Ranking the 10 Greatest Seasons by a Secondary in Ohio State History


Welcome to Glory Years, where we rank the top individual seasons in Ohio State football history.

Although Ohio State’s entrance to the DBU conversation has mostly revolved around its recent dominance, the Buckeyes’ success at the third level of defense has been well-documented for decades. With legends scattered all over Ohio State’s history, from Jack Tatum to Jeff Okudah, the Buckeyes have one of the deepest defensive backfields in college football history. Today, we’ll try to rank the greatest secondaries since 1970 by expanding on our previous Glory Years ratings.


For each year, we used our rankings for cornerbacks and safeties to determine the top four defensive backs by the ranking system. Unlike our previous rankings, however, our rankings of the best secondaries in program history are continuous, with points given for each of the following variables. The points for each variable is based on the rarity of the event. 

  • Tackles per Game
  • Tackles for Loss per Game
  • Pass-Breakups per Game
  • Pick-Sixes per Game
  • Chaos Factor

Altogether, the values for each variable and their associated point value was added together, meaning the highest score marks the best season. The following outputs were determined to be the ten greatest seasons by a secondary in Ohio State history.

10. 2013

After an undefeated season in 2012, the Buckeyes were ready for their first bowl-eligible season under Urban Meyer. The defensive backfield of C.J. Barnett, Bradley Roby, Doran Grant, and Armani Reeves proved to be one of the best in the country and returned two interceptions for touchdowns, tied for the seventh-best mark in program history. 

Roby earned First Team All-Big Ten honors following the season.  

9. 2012

In Urban Meyer’s inaugural, undefeated season, the tandem of Bradley Roby, C.J. Barnett, Travis Howard, and Orhian Johnson stepped up to the challenge. The secondary ranks third in pass break-ups per game, averaging three per contest. 

Roby earned All-American and All-Big Ten honors following his redshirt sophomore season. His play in 2012 ranks as the eighth-best season by a cornerback in program history. Howard earned First Team All-Big Ten honors from the media. 

8. 2003 

Coming off of a national championship, the 2002 Buckeyes were looking for another dominant season. Will Allen, Nate Salley, Dustin Fox, and Chris Gamble shored up the defensive backfield, averaging over 21 tackles per game, the fourth-best mark by a secondary in program history. 

Allen and Gamble each earned consensus All-Big Ten honors. Allen also planted a tree in Buckeye Grove following his senior year. Fox’s 2002 season is ranked as the 10th-best by a cornerback in program history. 

7. 1985

On one of the best defensive teams in Ohio State history, the secondary of Terry White, Sonny Gordon, Greg Rogan, and William White was the final obstacle after a grueling front seven. The group ranks first in chaos factor and third in tackles per game for a defensive backfield. 

Terry White earned All-Big Ten honors following the season. His junior season ranks as the second-best by a safety in program history and Gordon’s 1986 season is No. 3. 

6. 1996

After a disappointing end to the previous season, the Bucks looked to rebound in 1996. Damon Moore,

Rob Kelly, Shawn Springs, and Ty Howard averaged 2.5 pass-breakups per game, the fifth-best mark in program history. 

Springs earned a tree in Buckeye Grove following his superb sophomore season, which ranks the third-best season by a corner in Buckeye history. Moore also earned All-Big Ten honors following his season, which ranks as the best year by a safety in Ohio State history. 

5. 1981

Just a couple of years into Earle Bruce’s tenure, Shaun Gayle, Garcia Lane, Douglas Hill, and Kelvin Bell started their run of dominance in the secondary. The foursome ranks second in program history in pass-breakups per game, averaging over three per game. 

Lane’s sophomore season ranks as the sixth-best in program history while Bell’s 1983 season ranks as seventh. 

4. 2000

Led by the hard-hitting Mike Doss, the secondary to start the new millennium included Nate Clements, David Mitchell, and Derek Ross. The group averaged over 20 tackles per game, the seventh-best mark in program history. 

Clements and Doss both earned All-Big Ten honors after John Cooper’s final season in Columbus. Doss’ season ranks as the eighth-best by a safety in program history. 

3. 2016

Arguably one of the greatest secondaries of all time, the 2016 group of Malik Hooker, Marshon Lattimore, Gareon Conley, and Denzel Ward is the most dominant defensive backfield since the turn of the century. The secondary returned four interceptions for touchdowns, the best mark in program history. 

Hooker earned consensus All-American honors following his breakout campaign. Lattimore and Conley each earned All-Big Ten honors. Ward earned consensus All-American honors the following season. 

2. 1998

A part of one of the most talented teams in school history, Damon Moore, Antoine Winfield, Ahmed Plummer, and Nate Clements completed a fantastic stretch for Buckeye defensive backs. The foursome averaged 3.33 pass-breakups per game, the highest mark in program history. 

Antoine Winfield earned consensus All-American honors following his season, which ranks as the best year by a cornerback in program history. He also became the first Buckeye to win the Jim Thorpe Award. Moore and Plummer, whose 1998 seasons ranks No. 5, both earned All-Big Ten honors. 

1. 1997

The best defensive backfield in program history, the 1997 tandem of Antoine Winfield, Damon Moore, Gary Berry, and Ahmed Plummer take the crown. The secondary ranks in the top-ten for all of the categories, including fourth in chaos factor and fifth in pick-sixes. 

Winfield, after becoming the first defensive back to lead the Bucks in tackles, and Moore earned All-Big Ten honors following the season. Winfield was a non-consensus All-American as a junior. 

  Season TPG TFLPG PBU P6 Chaos Score
1 1997 19.77 1.23 2.38 0.15 1.46 12.17
2 1998 18.92 1.33 3.33 0.08 0.81 11.61
3 2016 12.62 0.50 2.31 0.31 1.15 10.95
4 2000 20.33 1.58 1.92 0.08 1.33 10.91
5 1981 17.58 0.75 3.08 0.00 1.17 10.78
6 1996 18.83 0.75 2.50 0.00 1.40 10.48
7 1985 21.42 0.58 1.75 0.00 1.67 10.48
8 2003 21.38 0.69 2.46 0.08 0.75 10.36
9 2012 16.50 0.42 3.00 0.08 0.83 10.30
10 2013 16.93 0.32 2.50 0.14 0.93 10.26
11 1999 25.33 1.25 1.92 0.00 0.83 10.11
12 2002 16.86 0.61 2.21 0.14 0.98 10.05
13 1989 19.67 0.83 1.67 0.08 1.25 9.93
14 2001 17.67 1.42 1.58 0.08 1.33 9.81
15 1979 21.58 0.75 1.67 0.00 1.31 9.75
16 2014 18.93 0.70 1.93 0.00 1.33 9.63
17 1987 18.45 1.18 1.55 0.09 1.16 9.53
18 1984 20.17 0.67 1.58 0.08 1.08 9.51
19 1983 16.17 0.33 2.08 0.00 1.50 9.49
20 2005 15.33 1.38 1.92 0.17 0.58 8.99

LEGEND: TPG Tackles per Game, TFLPG Tackles for Loss per Game, PBU Pass-Breakups per Game, P6 Pick-Sixes per Game


Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply